Cooking

Buttermilk Substitute: How to Make Buttermilk, and Which Swap Works Best

Make 1 cup of buttermilk with 1 tbsp lemon juice or vinegar plus milk, rested 5 minutes. Or use yogurt, kefir or sour cream, ranked for biscuits and pancakes.

Updated 8 min readBy CookEase

Quick answer: For 1 cup of buttermilk, put 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar in a measuring cup, add milk to the 1-cup line and wait 5 to 10 minutes.

Pick what you are making below: for biscuits, Greek yogurt with milk comes closer.

Find the right buttermilk substitute

What are you making?
Buttermilk in the recipe
1 cup
What you have

In most recipes the buttermilk's acid reacts with the baking soda for lift and keeps the crumb tender. Milk soured with lemon juice or vinegar brings that acid, and it is already in your fridge.

  1. A glass measuring cup of milk soured with lemon juice, showing fine curds, next to a cut lemon

    Milk and lemon juice

    Best pick

    1 tbsp lemon juice and enough milk to make 1 cup

    By weight: 15 g lemon juice and 230 g milk

    Pour the lemon juice into a measuring cup, add milk up to the line, stir once and leave it 5 to 10 minutes, until it thickens slightly and shows small curds.

    The classic swap, and the one university cooking guides give. Thinner and milder than real buttermilk, with the same lift.

  2. A glass of slightly curdled milk soured with vinegar, beside a small dish of clear vinegar and a spoon

    Milk and white vinegar

    1 tbsp white vinegar and enough milk to make 1 cup

    By weight: 15 g white vinegar and 230 g milk

    Same as lemon juice: vinegar in the cup first, milk to the line, then 5 to 10 minutes on the counter.

    Works exactly like lemon juice. In a bake you will not taste the vinegar.

  3. A glass bowl of plain yogurt whisked with milk into a thick, pourable liquid, with a whisk

    Greek yogurt and milk

    ⅓ cup plain Greek yogurt and ⅔ cup milk

    By weight: 83 g plain Greek yogurt and 165 g milk

    Whisk the yogurt and milk together until smooth, then use it right away, cold, where the recipe adds the buttermilk.

    The closest match in thickness and tang: King Arthur Baking ranked it right behind real buttermilk in biscuits and tied with it in pancakes.

Skip: Plain milk on its own. Without the acid, the baking soda has nothing to react with, so bakes come out flatter and darker.

The short answer

  • To make 1 cup of buttermilk, put 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar in a measuring cup, add milk up to the 1-cup line, stir, and let it stand 5 to 10 minutes until it thickens slightly and curdles.
  • For biscuits, where you taste the buttermilk, the closest match is plain Greek yogurt whisked with milk, about ⅓ cup yogurt and ⅔ cup milk per cup: in King Arthur Baking's test it came second only to real buttermilk in biscuits and tied with it in pancakes.
  • Plain yogurt, sour cream thinned with water, plain kefir, dried buttermilk powder, and 1¾ teaspoons of cream of tartar in 1 cup of milk all work too. Plain milk alone does not: it makes flat-tasting biscuits and denser, darker cakes.
  • For dairy-free buttermilk, stir 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar into 1 cup of unsweetened plant milk. It thickens less than dairy milk but bakes the same.
Swap it in a whole recipe

Swap the buttermilk in your recipe

Ranked for most recipes. Pick something else above to change the list.

Buttermilk biscuits, without buttermilk

  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 tbsp baking powder
  • 1/2 tsp baking soda
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 6 tbsp cold butter
  • 2¼ tsp lemon juice and enough milk to make ¾ cup (instead of ¾ cup buttermilk)
  • Pour the lemon juice into a measuring cup, add milk up to the line, stir once and leave it 5 to 10 minutes, until it thickens slightly and shows small curds.

Out of something else? See every ingredient substitute

How to make buttermilk with milk and lemon juice or vinegar

Homemade buttermilk is milk with a little acid stirred in. Use 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar for each cup, which is the amount every university cooking guide we checked gives, from Kansas State to Utah State, and the one King Arthur Baking uses. Put the acid in the cup first and fill with milk to the line, so the total is 1 cup, not 1 cup plus a tablespoon.

  1. A tablespoon of lemon juice being poured into an empty glass measuring cup, a squeezed lemon half on a plate beside it
    1. Lemon juice into a cup
  2. Milk being poured from a small glass bottle into the measuring cup on top of the lemon juice
    2. Milk to the 1-cup line
  3. A spoon lifted from the cup of soured milk, showing it slightly thickened with fine curds after resting
    3. Wait 5 to 10 minutes

Recipe

Homemade buttermilk with lemon juice or vinegar

Milk soured with a little acid, the standard buttermilk substitute in university cooking guides. It gives a batter the same lift with baking soda; it is thinner and milder than store-bought buttermilk.

Total time
10 min
Makes
Makes 1 cup

Ingredients

  • 1 tbsp lemon juice or white vinegar
  • Milk to make 1 cup (just under 1 cup)

Steps

  1. Pour the lemon juice or vinegar into a liquid measuring cup.
  2. Add milk up to the 1-cup line, so the total is 1 cup, and stir once.
  3. Leave it on the counter for 5 to 10 minutes, until it thickens very slightly and shows small curds.
  4. Stir it and use it in the same amount as the buttermilk in your recipe.

For other amounts, use 1 tablespoon of acid per cup: ¾ teaspoon for ¼ cup, 1½ teaspoons for ½ cup. With unsweetened plant milk, give it about 15 minutes; it thickens less but bakes the same.

Per serving (1 cup, made with whole milk): about 143 calories, 7 g protein, 12 g carbs, 7 g fat.

It will not get as thick as store-bought buttermilk, and that is fine: what a batter needs from it is the acid, which reacts with the baking soda. The chart below scales the acid for any amount the recipe asks for.

Buttermilk substitutes, and how much to use

Soured milk is the quickest, but it is not the only swap, and for some recipes not the best. Anything with the same tang and some of the same thickness will do the job.

Buttermilk substitute chart: what replaces 1 cup
SubstituteFor 1 cup
A glass measuring cup of milk soured with lemon juice, showing fine curds, next to a cut lemonMilk and lemon juice1 tbsp lemon juice and enough milk to make 1 cup15 g lemon juice and 230 g milkBest in: pancakes or waffles, cake or cupcakes, muffins or quick bread
A glass of slightly curdled milk soured with vinegar, beside a small dish of clear vinegar and a spoonMilk and white vinegar1 tbsp white vinegar and enough milk to make 1 cup15 g white vinegar and 230 g milkBest in: pancakes or waffles, cake or cupcakes, muffins or quick bread
A glass bowl of plain yogurt whisked with milk into a thick, pourable liquid, with a whiskGreek yogurt and milk⅓ cup plain Greek yogurt and ⅔ cup milk83 g plain Greek yogurt and 165 g milkBest in: biscuits or scones, pancakes or waffles, cake or cupcakes
A glass bowl of plain yogurt stirred smooth and loosened with a little liquid, with a whiskPlain yogurt1 cup plain yogurt245 g plain yogurtBest in: fried chicken marinade
A glass bowl of sour cream being thinned with a little water, a spoon resting in itSour cream thinned with water1 cup sour cream thinned with water until it pours like heavy cream230 g sour creamBest in: ranch or dressing
A glass of thick white kefir next to a plain glass bottle of kefirPlain kefir1 cup plain unsweetened kefir245 g kefirBest in: biscuits or scones, fried chicken marinade, ranch or dressing
A glass bowl of pale cream-colored dried buttermilk powder with a spoon in itDried buttermilk¼ cup dried buttermilk powder and 1 cup waterBest in: biscuits or scones
A small dish of white cream of tartar powder with a measuring spoon, beside a glass of milkMilk and cream of tartar1¾ tsp cream of tartar and 1 cup milkBest in: biscuits or scones, pancakes or waffles, cake or cupcakes
Amounts from King Arthur Baking and Kansas State Research and Extension; weights from USDA household measures.

Greek yogurt and milk is King Arthur Baking's blend, scaled down: one 5.3-ounce container of Greek yogurt with 1⅓ cups of milk makes 2 cups. Plain yogurt goes in cup for cup, as the Kansas State guide gives it; thin very thick yogurt, or sour cream, with a little water until it pours like heavy cream. Dried buttermilk is whisked into the dry ingredients, with the water added where the buttermilk would go. Cream of tartar gives the acid but none of the tang.

How much to use for the buttermilk in your recipe
ButtermilkLemon juice or vinegar, then milk to the lineGreek yogurt and milkDried buttermilk, plus the same water
¼ cup¾ tsp4 tsp plain Greek yogurt and 8 tsp milk1 tbsp
½ cup1½ tsp8 tsp plain Greek yogurt and ⅓ cup milk2 tbsp
⅔ cup2 tsp3½ tbsp plain Greek yogurt and 7 tbsp milk8 tsp
¾ cup2¼ tsp¼ cup plain Greek yogurt and ½ cup milk3 tbsp
1 cup1 tbsp⅓ cup plain Greek yogurt and ⅔ cup milk¼ cup
1½ cups1½ tbsp½ cup plain Greek yogurt and 1 cup milk6 tbsp
2 cups2 tbsp⅔ cup plain Greek yogurt and 1⅓ cups milk½ cup
Amounts from King Arthur Baking and Kansas State Research and Extension; weights from USDA household measures.

Which buttermilk substitute works best? What the tests found

King Arthur Baking baked the same biscuits, pancakes and cake with real buttermilk and with each common swap, and the results line up with what the buttermilk does in each one.

  • Real buttermilk

    Biscuits
    Best
    Pancakes
    Best
    Cake
  • Greek yogurt and milk

    Biscuits
    Second
    Pancakes
    Tied best
    Cake
  • Milk with vinegar or cream of tartar

    Biscuits
    Lacked flavor
    Pancakes
    Cake
  • Plain milk

    Biscuits
    Flat taste
    Pancakes
    Rose less
    Cake
    Darker, denser
From King Arthur Baking's side-by-side bakes. In cake, every swap worked except plain milk.
The best buttermilk substitute for each kind of recipe
MakingBest swapNext best
Biscuits or sconesGreek yogurt and milkDried buttermilk
Pancakes or wafflesGreek yogurt and milkMilk and lemon juice
Cake or cupcakesMilk and lemon juiceMilk and white vinegar
Muffins or quick breadMilk and lemon juiceGreek yogurt and milk
CornbreadMilk and lemon juiceGreek yogurt and milk
Fried chicken marinadePlain yogurtPlain kefir
Ranch or dressingPlain kefirGreek yogurt and milk
Ranked from King Arthur Baking's biscuit, pancake and cake tests and what the buttermilk does in each recipe.

Biscuits and scones

In biscuits you can taste the buttermilk, so thickness and tang matter. Greek yogurt and milk came closest in the test; dried buttermilk, kefir and plain yogurt are next. Soured milk still rises well, but the biscuits taste plainer.

Pancakes, waffles, muffins and cornbread

These mostly need the acid for lift, so milk with lemon juice or vinegar works well. Greek yogurt and milk tied with real buttermilk in pancakes.

Cakes, including red velvet

Every swap worked in King Arthur Baking's cake except plain milk, which made it darker and denser. Soured milk is the easy choice.

Fried chicken, ranch and dressings

Nothing is baked here, so the buttermilk's own tang and body carry the dish. Use kefir, plain yogurt or Greek yogurt with milk; soured milk is thin enough that a dressing turns runny and less coating clings to the chicken. Bon Appétit's editors go further and skip soured milk altogether, reaching for kefir or thinned yogurt whenever the buttermilk's flavor matters.

Dairy-free and vegan buttermilk

Stir 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar into 1 cup of unsweetened plant milk, such as soy, oat or almond, and let it rest about 15 minutes. King Arthur Baking notes that dairy-free soured milk does not thicken quite as much, but the result in your baking is the same. Pick Plant milk in the finder to see only the swaps that work with it.

Lemon juice or vinegar: which is better?

Neither. Both give the same acid in the same amount, and none of the guides we read prefers one. Use white vinegar when you have no lemons; use lemon juice when you will taste it, as in a dressing. Bottled lemon juice is fine.

Why recipes call for buttermilk

Buttermilk is acidic. In a batter with baking soda, that acid is what makes the bubbles, which is why King Arthur Baking calls it prized for its leavening ability when paired with baking soda. It also adds tang and makes cakes and biscuits tender. That is why plain milk falls short: without the acid, the baking soda has nothing to react with, and the bake comes out flatter and darker.

Keep the version that worked

Once a swap works, write it down. Save to CookEase on the recipe card, or under Swap it in a whole recipe, keeps it as a recipe in your cookbook, and you can edit any saved recipe to note the swap. Out of eggs as well? The egg substitute finder works the same way. There are finders for baking soda and baking powder too, and every ingredient substitute is on one page. To make half a batch of biscuits, the halving calculator does single amounts and the recipe converter resizes the whole recipe.

Keep every recipe the way you actually make it.

Save recipes from any link, video or photo, note your swaps, and cook from them step by step with the Cooking Assistant.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to use lemon juice or vinegar for buttermilk?

Either works, in the same amount: 1 tablespoon per cup of milk. University cooking guides and King Arthur Baking treat them as interchangeable. Lemon juice has a slightly fresher taste and white vinegar is neutral; once the batter is baked you will not taste either.

What do I use if I don't have buttermilk?

Make soured milk: 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar plus enough milk to make 1 cup, left 5 to 10 minutes. You can also use 1 cup of plain yogurt, plain kefir, Greek yogurt whisked with milk, sour cream thinned with water, or 1¾ teaspoons of cream of tartar mixed into 1 cup of milk.

How long does it take for milk to turn to buttermilk?

About 5 to 10 minutes at room temperature after you stir in the lemon juice or vinegar. It is ready when it has thickened slightly and you can see small curds. King Arthur Baking gives it up to 15 minutes, and plant milk takes about 15.

Can I use sour cream instead of buttermilk?

Yes. Thin the sour cream with water or milk until it pours like heavy cream, then use the same amount as the buttermilk. It works well in biscuits, cakes and dressings and gives a richer result.

Can I use regular milk instead of buttermilk?

Not on its own. Buttermilk's acid reacts with the baking soda in the recipe, and without it King Arthur Baking's plain-milk biscuits tasted flat, its pancakes rose less and its cake came out darker and denser. Add 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar per cup first.

How do you make buttermilk dairy-free?

Stir 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar into 1 cup of unsweetened plant milk, such as soy, oat or almond, and let it rest about 15 minutes. It thickens less than dairy milk, but King Arthur Baking finds the baked result is the same.

Can I use Greek yogurt instead of buttermilk?

Yes, thinned with milk: whisk about ⅓ cup of plain Greek yogurt with ⅔ cup of milk for each cup of buttermilk. It is the closest swap in thickness and tang, and King Arthur Baking ranked it right behind real buttermilk in biscuits. Plain regular yogurt works cup for cup.

Can you freeze buttermilk?

Yes. Freeze it in measured portions, such as ½ cup in a small container or tablespoons in an ice cube tray, so you thaw only what a recipe needs. It separates a little as it thaws, so whisk or shake it before using it, and use it for baking, pancakes or marinades rather than for drinking.

How do you use buttermilk powder?

For each cup of buttermilk, whisk ¼ cup of dried buttermilk into the dry ingredients and add 1 cup of water where the recipe adds the buttermilk.

Sources

  1. Buttermilk substitute: What to use, King Arthur Baking
  2. Why you should be keeping dried buttermilk in your pantry, King Arthur Baking
  3. Non-dairy milk for baking: What's the best choice?, King Arthur Baking
  4. Ingredient Substitutions (L730), Kansas State Research and Extension
  5. List of Ingredient Substitutions for Cooking and Baking, Utah State University Extension
  6. Substitutions for Common Ingredients, University of Illinois Extension
  7. How to Substitute Buttermilk, and When You Shouldn’t, Bon Appétit

Keep reading