Cooking

Brown Sugar Substitute: How to Make Brown Sugar and What Else Works

No brown sugar? Mix 1 cup white sugar with 2 tsp molasses for light brown, or 1 tbsp for dark. Amounts for any recipe, and what to use with no molasses.

6 min readBy CookEase

Quick answer: For 1 cup of light brown sugar, mix 1 cup of granulated sugar with 2 teaspoons of molasses.

For dark brown sugar, use 1 tablespoon of molasses. No molasses? Pick what you are making below for the next best swap.

Find the right brown sugar substitute

What are you making?
The recipe calls for
Brown sugar, packed
1 cup
Leave out

In cookies, brown sugar brings moisture and a caramel taste, and its molasses is a mild acid that works with the baking soda.

  1. Dark molasses drizzling from a spoon onto a glass bowl of white sugar

    White sugar and molasses

    Best pick

    1 cup granulated sugar and 2 tsp molasses

    By weight: 200 g granulated sugar and 14 g molasses

    Mash the molasses into the sugar with a fork until the color is even, or add both to the bowl with the butter: King Arthur Baking says there is no need to mix them first.

    This is brown sugar: white sugar with molasses in it. It bakes and tastes the same, with the same soft, moist texture.

  2. A small bowl of light brown sugar next to a small bowl of darker brown sugar

    The other brown sugar

    1 cup dark brown sugar, packed

    By weight: 220 g dark brown sugar

    Use the same amount, packed into the cup the same way.

    Light and dark brown sugar work the same in a recipe, King Arthur Baking says. Dark has more molasses, so it tastes a little deeper and makes a darker bake.

  3. A small glass bowl of white granulated sugar with a measuring cup

    White sugar alone

    1 cup granulated sugar

    By weight: 200 g granulated sugar

    Use the same amount. Expect a paler bake with less caramel taste.

    It works, but King Arthur Baking calls the results unpredictable: cookies may spread more or less than usual, and cakes and muffins may not rise as well.

The short answer

  • Make your own: 1 cup of granulated sugar with 2 teaspoons of molasses for light brown sugar, or 1 tablespoon for dark. Mash it together with a fork, or add both straight to the recipe.
  • Light and dark brown sugar swap cup for cup. Dark just tastes a little deeper and bakes darker.
  • No molasses? Fine-grained turbinado or other raw sugar works in cakes, and plain white sugar works anywhere, though cookies can spread differently and cakes may rise a little less.
Swap it in a whole recipe

Swap the brown sugar in your recipe

Ranked for cookies. A line that says light or dark keeps its own kind.

Chocolate chip cookies, without brown sugar

  • 2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 tsp baking soda
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 1 cup butter, softened
  • 3/4 cup granulated sugar
  • ¾ cup granulated sugar (instead of ¾ cup light brown sugar)
  • 1½ tsp molasses
  • 2 large eggs
  • 2 cups chocolate chips
  • Mash the molasses into the sugar with a fork until the color is even, or add both to the bowl with the butter: King Arthur Baking says there is no need to mix them first.

Out of something else? See every ingredient substitute

How to make brown sugar

Brown sugar is white sugar with molasses in it: King Arthur Baking describes store-bought brown sugar as refined sugar with molasses added back, up to about 10 percent by weight. So the best substitute is the real thing, made at home in a minute. King Arthur Baking's ratio is 1 cup of granulated sugar with 2 teaspoons of molasses for light brown sugar, or 1 tablespoon for dark. Mash it together with a fork until the color is even and the sugar feels soft and damp.

Recipe

Homemade brown sugar

Granulated sugar with molasses worked in, which is all brown sugar is. King Arthur Baking's ratio, for light or dark brown sugar.

Total time
5 min
Makes
Makes 1 cup

Ingredients

  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 2 tsp molasses for light brown sugar, or 1 tbsp for dark

Steps

  1. Put the sugar in a bowl and drizzle the molasses over it.
  2. Mash and stir with a fork, pressing out the dark streaks, until the color is even and the sugar feels soft and damp. A food processor does it in a few pulses.
  3. Measure it packed into the cup, like store-bought brown sugar. Keep it in a closed jar so it stays soft.

Baking right away? Skip the mixing: add the sugar and molasses to the bowl separately, with the butter.

Per serving (1 tbsp): about 51 calories, 0 g protein, 13 g carbs, 0 g fat.

Homemade brown sugar: white sugar and molasses for any amount
Brown sugar, packedGranulated sugarMolasses, light / dark
¼ cup¼ cup½ tsp / ¾ tsp
⅓ cup⅓ cup⅝ tsp / 1 tsp
½ cup½ cup1 tsp / 1½ tsp
⅔ cup⅔ cup1⅜ tsp / 2 tsp
¾ cup¾ cup1½ tsp / 2¼ tsp
1 cup1 cup2 tsp / 1 tbsp
1½ cups1½ cups1 tbsp / 1½ tbsp
2 cups2 cups4 tsp / 2 tbsp
2 teaspoons of molasses per cup of granulated sugar for light brown sugar, 1 tablespoon for dark (King Arthur Baking).

Any ordinary molasses works, light or dark; blackstrap molasses is much more bitter, so use less of it or save it for gingerbread. If you are baking right away, King Arthur Baking says there is no need to mix the two first: add the sugar and the molasses to the bowl separately, along with the butter. Homemade brown sugar weighs close to store-bought, so the recipe needs no other change.

What can I use instead of brown sugar?

  • The other brown sugar. Light and dark brown sugar work the same in a recipe, King Arthur Baking says, so use whichever you have, cup for cup. Dark gives a deeper taste and a darker bake.
  • Turbinado, demerara or muscovado. These raw sugars keep some molasses. King Arthur Baking found turbinado works well in cake, but makes drop cookies spread more. Pick the finest-grained one you have.
  • White sugar alone. Kansas State lists it cup for cup. It works, but King Arthur Baking calls the results unpredictable: cookies may spread more or less, and cakes and muffins may not rise as well.

Using white sugar instead of brown sugar

Brown sugar does three things white sugar does not. Its molasses holds on to moisture, which keeps cookies soft. It brings a caramel taste. And it is mildly acidic: King Arthur Baking's leavening guide lists brown sugar among the acids that set off baking soda. Take the molasses away and all three change a little, which is why a cookie made with white sugar alone can come out crisper and paler, and why a cake that rises on baking soda may rise a little less.

When white sugar works best

King Arthur Baking finds the swap most reliable in recipes that use baking powder rather than baking soda, and where brown sugar is a small part of the sugar. In a crumble topping, oatmeal or a quick glaze, white sugar works fine; add a drop of vanilla for a little of the warmth the molasses would have brought.

Light or dark: does it matter?

Not to how the recipe works. King Arthur Baking says the two function the same and differ only in color and taste: dark brown sugar has more molasses, so it bakes a little darker and tastes deeper. Swap one for the other cup for cup. To turn light brown sugar into dark, work about 1 more teaspoon of molasses into each cup; to make dark brown sugar taste like light, mix 2 parts of it with 1 part white sugar.

Cookies, cakes, glazes and toppings

  • Cookies: homemade brown sugar first, then the other brown sugar. White sugar works, though the cookies can come out crisper. Coarse raw sugar makes them spread more.
  • Cakes, muffins and quick breads: homemade brown sugar, the other brown sugar, or fine turbinado, which King Arthur Baking found works well in cake.
  • Ham glaze, barbecue sauce and marinades: white sugar with molasses gives back the flavor these are built on.
  • Oatmeal, streusel and sweet potatoes: any brown or raw sugar; the crunch of turbinado is a bonus here.

Swaps that do not work as well

Careful with

Coarse raw sugar in drop cookies, which spread more. Blackstrap molasses in the same amount as regular. Liquid sweeteners like maple syrup or honey cup for cup, which add liquid the recipe did not plan for.

Safe bets

White sugar with 2 teaspoons of molasses per cup for light brown, 1 tablespoon for dark. Light for dark or dark for light, cup for cup. Fine turbinado in cakes.

Keep the version that worked

Save the recipe with the swap already in it: the Save to CookEase buttons on the recipe card and under Swap it in a whole recipe keep it in your cookbook, and you can edit any saved recipe to note what you used. Baking cookies for the holidays? See the baking soda, cream of tartar and egg substitutes, make your own pumpkin pie spice, or scale a batch with the recipe converter. Every swap is on our ingredient substitutes page.

Keep every recipe the way you actually make it.

Save recipes from any link, video or photo, note your swaps, and cook from them step by step with the Cooking Assistant.

Frequently asked questions

How do you make brown sugar?

Mix 1 cup of granulated sugar with 2 teaspoons of molasses for light brown sugar, or 1 tablespoon for dark brown sugar. Mash it with a fork until the color is even, or pulse it in a food processor. In a recipe, King Arthur Baking says you can simply add the sugar and molasses separately.

Can I use white sugar instead of brown sugar?

Yes, cup for cup, but expect some difference. King Arthur Baking calls the results unpredictable: cookies may spread more or less than usual and cakes and muffins may not rise as well, because brown sugar adds moisture and a little acid. It works best in recipes that use baking powder.

Can I use light brown sugar instead of dark?

Yes, in the same amount. Light and dark brown sugar work the same way in a recipe; dark has more molasses, so it gives a deeper taste and color. To turn 1 cup of light brown sugar into dark, mix in about 1 teaspoon of molasses.

How do you make brown sugar without molasses?

You cannot quite make it without molasses, since molasses is what makes sugar brown. Use a fine-grained raw sugar like turbinado or demerara in the same amount instead, or plain white sugar. Some people use maple syrup or honey, but those are liquids and change the recipe more.

How much molasses do I add to white sugar for brown sugar?

2 teaspoons per cup of granulated sugar for light brown sugar and 1 tablespoon per cup for dark, which is King Arthur Baking's ratio. For ½ cup, use 1 teaspoon for light or 1½ teaspoons for dark.

Sources

  1. What can I substitute for brown sugar?, King Arthur Baking
  2. Light vs. dark brown sugar: What's the difference?, King Arthur Baking
  3. What's the difference between baking soda and baking powder?, King Arthur Baking
  4. Ingredient Substitutions (L730), Kansas State Research and Extension

Keep reading